Switching National Football Leagues: General Thoughts

-
One of the important issues in European football concerns the ability of a football club to participate in a national football league, other than the one of its original registration. This is also an important issue for the practice of sports law. Any analysis, therefore, would encompass a wide variety of different considerations. 

For the sports lawyer, the first consideration would focus on the regulatory framework of UEFA and possibly the one of FIFA. The CAS jurisprudence, where applicable, may also be of great assistance. For the lay person, the primary consideration would be, perhaps, the competitiveness of the league the club is switching to and secondly, the geographical position of the new league.

For the Board of the club, the primary consideration would, perhaps, be the financial viability of the club in the short term and the commercial opportunities in the long term. The financial aspect must not be ignored and, here, we have a clash of the two important sports law principles of 'win-maximisation' and 'profit-maximisation.' These two principles are different in nature, although their application may depend on one another. The Board, would have to make an important decision as to which one would apply to its decision making process in the new league.

There are other important considerations too and they may depend on the name and the history of the club in question. Certain considerations would apply to the situation where the club's following is limited, as opposed to a club whose following is global. The latter would obviously be more attractive in terms of commercial opportunities and the hosting league/association would have to seriously consider the benefits of accepting such club into its league.

There are obviously enormous hurdles against such a possible switch from one national league to another. In the absence of a specific regulatory prohibition, a switch may be possible. However, it is almost certain that UEFA and FIFA may raise concerns against such development, by putting forward the argument that this situation is undesirable, as it may distort competition and create an embarrassing precedence. 

At this juncture we would have, without a doubt, a complicated legal analysis, not so much regarding the ability of a club to move to another national league, but on whether the governing body is within its rights to block such move. We may need to consider several different areas of sports law and other principles, such as the 'sporting exception', issues of competition law, restraint of trade, contract law and employment law.

This is an important aspect of the modern professional game and given the European Commission's unambiguous position on the enlargement of the European Union and the free movement of persons and services within the European Union, it may not be too long before the European Court of Justice is forced to hear similar submissions. 

I, for sure, have my Brief ready....

Dr. Gregory Ioannidis

23 May 2012


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Preliminary (Provisional) & Conservatory Measures before the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS): Procedure & Practice.

-
Image
  An important aspect of procedure and practice before the CAS, relates to the ability of applicants to seek urgent protective measures, in the form of an application for a Stay of execution of the appealed decision. The legal basis for such application can be identified in Article 183 of Swiss Private International Law and R37 of the CAS Code. The latter, provides that the CAS may, upon request of a party, order preliminary or protective measures. According to CAS practice and jurisprudence (See  CAS 2003/O/486; CAS 2013/A/3324; CAS 2013/A/3199; CAS 2010/A/2071. CAS 2001/A/329; CAS 2001/A/324 ), there is a three-stage test that needs to be satisfied for a successful application on such protective measures (provided that the issue of jurisdiction has been settled): The requested measures must be necessary to protect the Applicant from irreparable harm; There must be a likelihood of success on the merits of the claim; The interests of the Applicant in the ...
Read more

An Insight into the World of Football Transfers

-
Image
This is an interesting, unique and controversial area of modern sport that deserves further examination. Football transfers are, of course, not a new phenomenon. A series of important developments, however, such as the modern and increased commercialisation of sport, as well as the implications and consequences of the decision in the Bosman case, have created a complex framework of individuals, regulations and financial opportunities that determine the present situation. 
Read more

A Civil Action: Recipe for Disaster?

-
The developments in Scottish football, this year, have been astonishing and rather controversial. For the sports lawyer, this is a remarkable opportunity to examine and critically analyse further the perennial battle between state regulation and self-regulation. Rangers have certainly given us this opportunity with their decision to challenge the transfer embargo imposed on them, by submitting an application to a civil court in Scotland. Irrespective of the Scottish court's decision, the question remains whether the football authorities in Scotland would impose further sanctions on Rangers as a result of this development.
Read more